SEMARANG, Mediajateng.net – Penuntasan perselisihan hasil Pilkada selama ini dinilai belum memenuhi rasa keadilan elektoral. Hal itu disebabkan karena ada batas ambang batas minimal selisih jumlah suara dan juga batas waktu yang ditentukan.

Penilaian ini mengemuka dalam sebuah seminar nasional tentang Pemilu di Fakultas Hukum Undip. Menghadirkan pembicara Dr. Hasyim Asy’ari, PhD (Komisioner KPU), Bu Dr. Sri Wahyu Ananingsih, SH.MHum (BAwaslu Jateng), Prof M. Guntur Hamzah (Sekjen MK), dan Prof M. Fauzan (Guru Besar HTN FH UNSOED), dan Denny Septiviant SH (praktisi advokat Pilkada).

Komisioner KPU, Dr Hasyim Asy’ari menuturkan bahwa sejarah penyelesaian pilkada dan pemilu secara umum melalui pengadilan, dimulai dari Jawa Tengah. Saat itu pada Pilkada 2015 di Kabupaten Pemalang ada selisih penghitungan suara.

“Saat itu oleh salah satu pasangan calon, kasus ini dibawa ke Mahkamah Konstitusi. Atas hal ini, saya menaruh hormat kepada mas Denny Septiviant yang berinisiatif mendaftarkan gugatan ke MK. Dan akhirnya ini menjadi preseden solusi yang sangat baik karena tak ada anarkisme,” kata Hasyim.

Denny sendiri bercerita, sebagai advokat, ia akhirnya terlibat dalam sejumlah Pilkada mulai tahun 2015, 2017 dan 2018 di sejumlah daerah. Gagasannya memanfaatkan MK sebagai upaya meredam kekerasan akhirnya menjadi tren.

“Namun ketika semua sengketa elektoral berujung perselisihan, tentu MK menjadi sangat sibuk. Prinsip peradilan yang mekanismenya sederhana, waktu singkat, dan murah mengharuskan Bawaslu diperkuat posisinya,” kata Denny, Senin (10/9/2018).

Penguatan Bawaslu itu akan memberi kepuasan dan meningkatkan kepercayaan publik karena sengketanya diselesaikan secara terbuka dan partisipatif (musyawarah). “Akan lebih baik lagi jika dibentuk peradilan khusus kepemiluan secara ad hoc,” kata Denny.

Ide pembentukan peradilan ad hoc kepemiluan itu didasari pengalaman bahwa ambang batas minimal selisih jumlah suara dan batas waktu tersebut menjadi problem di lapangan. Persoalan-persoalan di hulu seperti money politik dan kecurangan-kecurangan lain tidak terselesaikan dengan sempurna.

Atas ide ini, Sekjen Mahkamah konstitusi Guntur Hamzah menyebut bahwa lontaran itu jika direalisasi akan mengurangi beban persidangan di MK. Biasanya menjadi bertele-tele karena harus menyidangkan dalil-dalil seputar kecurangan sebelum pemungutan suara.

“Terkait ambang batas minimal selisih jumlah suara, saya kira perlu kajian lebih lanjut,” kata Guntur.

44 KOMENTAR

  1. tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription purchasing cialis on the internet reviews cialisonl.com
    tadalafil 10 mg daily http://cialisonl.com/
    buy cialis online cheap http://cialisonl.com/
    tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription
    comparatif cialis viagra levitracialis for anginacheap viagra cialisgeneric cialis online fast shippingwaarom werkt cialis nietgeneric cialis 350cialis fda approvalcialis forced orgasmbuy cialis soft online a hrefcialis dreampharmaceuticals from
    http://atlanticpacificmanagement.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com
    buy cialis online without prescription

  2. tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription cheap cialis cialissv.com
    tadalafil tablets 40mg http://cialissv.com/
    buy cheap cialis coupon http://cialissv.com/
    cialis without a doctor’s prescription
    viagra cialis candian pharmacy safecialis online consultationviagra or cialis kaufendoes cialis help premature ejaculationcialis once a day does it work
    http://elcaminoshoptalk.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialissv.com
    generic cialis without prescription

  3. cialis without a doctors prescription tadalafil 20 mg troche cialissv.com
    cialis generic prices http://cialissv.com/
    tadalafil 20 mg best price http://cialissv.com/
    cialis canada prescription
    generic cialis super active 20 mgu id password cialisanti cialis impotenceervaringen cialis once a daymelhor cialis levitra viagrainsurance companies cialislegally buy cialis on lineviagra x cialis x levitra precos
    http://caligormedical.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialissv.com
    order cialis without prescription

  4. cialis purchase online without prescription purchase cialis cialisonl.com
    cialis prices 5mg http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis tablets for sale http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis without a doctors prescription
    cialis en diabetescialis drug cost comparewhat is the best amino acid alternative to cialis soft2003 case studies of cialiscomparativa entre viagra y cialisquick forum readtopic cialis signature onlinetadalafil generic cialislegally buy cialis on line
    http://tapspace.info/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com
    cialis without a doctor prescription

  5. cialis purchase online without prescription tadalafil 20 mg best price cialissi.com
    cialis 20 mg price http://cialissi.com/
    cialis online usa http://cialissi.com/
    cialis without a doctors prescription
    legalidad de comprar cialiscomparison study of viagra cialis levitraventajas de cialis sobre viagraliasons sp cialis esdiscount levitra cialis viagrakey achat cialischinese cialis 50 mg
    http://the-upperoom-store.org/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialissi.com
    cialis canada prescription

  6. get cialis prescription online buy cialis with no prescription cialisonl.com
    tadalafil 10 mg best price http://cialisonl.com/
    buy cialis with no prescription http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis purchase online without prescription
    effect van cialisbuying cialis online safelycialis reviews drugs.comdifferences entre viagra cialis levitracompare cialis pricesin welchen landern kann man cialis rezeptfrei kaufencialis viagra or levitra which is bestcialis den haag
    http://scaa-spill.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com
    canadian pharmacy no prescription cialis

  7. cialis without a doctors prescription cialis generico opinion cialissi.com
    tadalafil 10 mg troche http://cialissi.com/
    cialis 5mg prix http://cialissi.com/
    cialis without a doctors prescription
    stay hard cialistucson cialiscialis in canadaviagra e cialis effetti collateraliwat zijn cialis pillenmelanger viagra et cialis20 mg cialis dose advicepros and cons of viagra and cialisu 3312 viagra cialiscialis alcohol consumption
    http://mannmademovies.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialissi.com

  8. buy cialis online cialis lowest prices md pharmacy issuu.com/cialisprofessional
    cialis generico https://issuu.com/cialisprofessional
    canada cialis https://issuu.com/cialisprofessional
    buy cheap cialis in canada
    mas efectivo viagra o cialisusa cialiscialis generika rezeptfrei aus deutschlandcialis black reviewcialis europe viagracialis internet sat?smelange viagra cialiscialis severe headachecialis works better than expectedcialis in france
    http://panmateria.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=issuu.com/cialisprofessional

  9. cialis without a doctor’s prescription tadalafil generic name cialisonl.com
    cialis online canada http://cialisonl.com/
    generic for cialis medication http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis purchase online without prescription
    do viagra and cialis work the same waydaily cialis with viagrawhen cialis does not help edwhat’s safer viagra or cialisis it ok to take cialis and viagra togetheralternative to cialis
    http://internationaltennisfederation.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com

  10. canadian prescriptions online serc 24 mg canadian prescriptions online serc 24 mg canadianpharmacyonli.com
    canadian prescriptions online serc 24 mg http://canadianpharmacyonli.com/
    online pharmacies of canada http://canadianpharmacyonli.com/
    canada pharmacy online
    pharmacy canadaonline pharmacies tech schoolcanadian pharmaceuticals naftadrugs for sale in canadacanadian pharmacy online 24
    http://tradingdogs.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=canadianpharmacyonli.com

  11. online pharmacies canada drugstore online india canadianpharmacytousa.com
    online canadian pharmacies http://canadianpharmacytousa.com/
    northwest pharmacy canada http://canadianpharmacytousa.com/
    canadian pharmacy king
    canada viagratop rated canadian pharmacies onlinecanadian prescriptions online serc 24 mgdrugs for sale in mexicopharmacy canada bestbuy viagra online usapharmacy canada online prescriptionsare canadian online pharmacies safeonline pharmacies indiacanada medications buy
    http://touriosity.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=canadianpharmacytousa.com

  12. canada medication pharmacy canadian medications by mail canadianpharmacytousa.com
    canada online pharmacies http://canadianpharmacytousa.com/
    canada online pharmacies legitimate http://canadianpharmacytousa.com/
    canadian pharcharmy online24
    canadian online pharmaciescanadian prescription drugstoretrust pharmacy canadiancanadian discount pharmacies in ocala flnorthwest pharmacies onlinedrugs for sale deep webcanadian government approved pharmacies
    http://touriosity.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=canadianpharmacytousa.com

  13. online pharmacies online drug store canadianpharmacyies.com
    drugs for sale usa http://canadianpharmacyies.com/
    legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies http://canadianpharmacyies.com/
    trust pharmacy canadian
    canadian government approved pharmaciesdrugstore online indiabest canadian pharmacypharmacy canada 24canadian online pharmacybuy viagra nowdrugs for sale in ukcanadian pharmaceuticals stocksorder canadian prescriptions onlinecanadian pharmacy uk delivery
    п»їhttp://iluvglhec.biz/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=canadianpharmacyies.com

  14. drugstore online Canadian Pharmacy USA canadianpharmacyies.com
    trust pharmacy canadian http://canadianpharmacyies.com/
    canadian prescriptions online serc 24 mg http://canadianpharmacyies.com/
    canada medications information
    legitimate canadian mail order pharmaciescanadian pharcharmy online24buy viagrownorth west pharmacies canadacanada online pharmacypharmacy canada plusaarp recommended canadian online pharmaciesnorthwest pharmacies onlineonline pharmacies mexico
    п»їhttp://iluvglhec.biz/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=canadianpharmacyies.com

  15. online canadian pharmacy buy viagra usa canadianpharmacyonli.com
    canadian rx http://canadianpharmacyonli.com/
    canadian pharmacycanadian pharmacy http://canadianpharmacyonli.com/
    canadian pharmaceuticals online
    canadian cialiscanada medication pharmacyprescription drugs without prior prescriptiondrugs for sale usaNorthwest Pharmacyhow safe are canadian online pharmaciesdrugstore online reviewsonline pharmacies legitimate
    http://tradingdogs.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=canadianpharmacyonli.com

  16. buy cialis online cheap buy cialis germany cialisvv.com
    buy tadalafil online http://cialisvv.com/
    cialis pills http://cialisvv.com/
    Cialis pills
    where to puchase cialis onlinecialis daily use side effectscialis 20 mg duracion efectocialis generika in niederlandeorder cialis soft cash on deliverydiferencias entre el viagra cialis y levitracialis vs viagra mejoru 11146 cialisviagra cialis levitra italiaviagra vs cialis uk
    http://cactus-club-boston.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisvv.com

  17. buy cialis online us pharmacy cialis 5mg price comparison cialisvi.com
    tadalafil generic dosage http://cialisvi.com/
    cialis generic 60 mg http://cialisvi.com/
    buy cialis us pharmacy
    how long it takes to ship cialis softcialis cures performance anxietycialis in regulare pharmacys switzerlandorder cialis soft 20 pills1buy canada cialiscialis overnighitc exclusion cialislevitra cialis for womencompare cialis prices
    http://reidtherapeuticprotocolfoundation.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisvi.com

  18. tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription cialis pharmacy cialisonli.com
    cialis 20mg use http://cialisonli.com/
    tadalafil 10 mg 180 pills http://cialisonli.com/
    cialis purchase online without prescription
    generic cialis online indiadifference of viagra and cialislegally buy cialis on linesubaction showcomments cialis smile onlinecialis outdatedcialis soft discount fedex no prescriptioncialis to buycialis 10 mg tadalafil filmtabletten (lilly deutschland)cialis junto viagra
    http://mcloones.biz/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonli.com

  19. real cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis online best price cialissy.com
    cialis 20 mg coupon http://cialissy.com/
    generic for cialis daily 5 mg http://cialissy.com/
    cialis without a doctors prescription
    biblioth ques sp cialis staking viagra and cialis togetherviagra and cialis used togethergeneric names for cialis softcialis 10mg effectscialis soft 2 day deliveryimpotence drugs cialiscialis 5 mg tratamiento diariosta je bolje cialis ili viagra
    http://holidaytherapy.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialissy.com

  20. cialis purchase online without prescription cialis 5mg price comparison cialisonl.com
    generic for cialis daily 5 mg available when http://cialisonl.com/
    buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis without doctor prescription
    cialis kopen utrechtcialis soft in koreacialis avoid headachecialis cheap online a hrefwhat does cialis look likeque es mejor cialis viagracialis daily dose generic
    http://metlifegulfagency.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com

  21. cialis without a doctor’s prescription tadalafil tablets 20 mg dosage cialisonl.com
    buy cials online http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis uk suppliers http://cialisonl.com/
    buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription
    kj pe cialiscialis viagra onlinephoenix liqide cialiscialis original kaufen ohne rezeptweekend pill cialiscialis vs viagra market sharetucson cialiscialis es igual al viagracialis ve viagra kars?last?rmas?
    http://callmaxplus.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com

  22. can you buy cialis without a prescription cialis generico en mexico cialisonl.com
    generic cialis tadalafil india http://cialisonl.com/
    tadalafil 5mg daily http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis purchase online without prescription
    viagra vs cialis vs levitra 2018what is more powerful viagra or cialissubaction showcomments cialis archive onlineequivalent cialis viagrarefractory time cialisfake cialischeap cialis soft over night
    http://herrmannsolutions.net/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com

  23. cialis without a doctor prescription cialis tablets australia cialisonl.com
    cialis 5 mg price walmart http://cialisonl.com/
    tadalafil 10 mg daily http://cialisonl.com/
    cialis without a doctor 25
    cialis and lisinoprilcialis cocaineoriginele cialis kopenfake cialis safegeneric cialis 24100 2f 20mgdiscounted cialis 20 mgcombining viagra and cialisviagra vs cialis user reviewswhat color pill is cialis
    http://schlechty.org/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com

  24. cialis without a doctor 20mg buy cialis no rx cialisonl.com
    cialis 20 mg best price broomfield http://cialisonl.com/
    generic cialis from uk http://cialisonl.com/
    real cialis without a doctors prescription
    coffee and cialis softcialis soft 2 day deliveryviagra mejor que cialiscomparar viagra cialisside effects of mixing viagra and cialisgeneric cialis canada pharmacyalternativa al viagra or cialiscialis rezeptfrei billig kaufen wo
    http://lucix.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=cialisonl.com

Comments are closed.